Is Small the New Big?
Aug 11th, 2015 by
Prateep Basu, NSR
The gods have been good to space entrepreneurs lately,
showering them with unprecedented amount of venture capital
funds on business plans revolving around nano- and
microsatellite based operations. The hype and expectations
surrounding these space startups has set the industry abuzz with
mixed opinions on their success and business model
sustainability. A platform primarily used for technology
demonstration and university missions, small satellites have
found favor with the business and financial community for
implementing business models that disrupt the traditional space
business and open up a plethora of new markets based on
downstream applications like image analytics, asset tracking,
and high-speed data connectivity.
Among the many potential applications of these small
satellites, NSR’s Nano and Microsatellite Markets, 2nd
Edition found that Earth observation (EO) has emerged as
key driver for this industry’s growth, with large
constellations being planned and deployed by startups such as
Planet Labs, Spire, Satellogic, PlanetiQ, and Black Sky Global,
to name a few. Earth Observation, a market dominated by defense
& intelligence needs, scores above other small satellite
applications due to a situation of ‘data poverty’ in industry
verticals such as agriculture, disaster management, forestry and
wildlife, and financial services. In its research, NSR found
that 40% of the nano and microsatellites planned to be launched
by the end of year 2024 will be for EO applications, which will
contribute a staggering 58% of the total manufacturing
market (~ $400 million).
The demand for EO services using nano/microsatellites is
primarily being driven by consumer-oriented and data-driven
applications that operators are hoping will unlock previously
untapped markets. But the key question here is which of these
new markets are ready to adopt and pay for such innovative
services that they do not completely understand, and above that,
what will be the differentiating factors for source agnostic EO
product users in the upcoming scenario of oversupply?
Most of these small satellite operators are currently
organized in a vertically integrated manner. Though such an
approach provides greater control over the product, the
operating costs far outweigh the operating revenues for Silicon
Valley based firms until their systems and target markets are
fully established. So it comes as no surprise that established
firms are being targeted by cash-rich EO start-ups for getting
access to stable revenue streams and rich image archives.
NSR considers the nano/microsatellite market to be still in
its early stage of development, with best practices and
operational strategy still evolving. The trade-offs between
asset performance, accessibility to launch services, and
business profitability will drive small satellite operators to
find that ‘sweet spot’ in sizing the satellite. Hence, the
iterations of constellation and satellite size is expected to
continue while more consolidation happens in this industry to
keep a check on the holy grail of ‘costs vs revenues’ debate.
The fortunate companies which survive this phase will surely set
new standards in the satellite industry in terms of innovation
in manufacturing, operations, and sales strategy. It is
therefore no surprise that established firms like SSL, Thales
Alenia Space and Airbus D&S have made a move into small
satellite either directly or through subsidiaries.
Bottom Line
Nano/microsatellites have definitely arrived as a reliable
and low-barrier means of entry to satellite markets, and offer
more synergies than threats to established large satellite
manufacturers and operators. Though buzz words like ‘Big Data
Analytics’ and ‘low-cost access to space’ are helping small
satellites to increase the dynamism in satellite industry, the
key issue of striking the right balance between investor
expectations and business model execution capability still
remains unanswered. NSR expects current small satellite
business models to evolve in the near-future towards adoption of
slightly larger form factors for nanosatellites, giving
operators the necessary breathing space to actually focus on
harvesting the data and employing it in unique end-user
applications.